Cumulonimbus Cloud

When is air stable or unstable ?

Meteorologists often talk about the atmosphere being either stable or unstable. But what does this mean?

What do stability and instability look like?

The clearest way to observe the difference between a stable and an unstable air mass is to look at the clouds:

  1. A stable atmosphere will have largely flat layers of cloud which, although they may exhibit some lumpiness, will not extend far upwards. There may be several such layers or occasionally, clear skies.
  1. Unstable air will generally have tall cauliflower-like clouds known as cumulus, These grow quickly and are associated with showers of heavy rain. Some get so tall that ice forms near their tops, giving a fluffy, bright white appearance to what is called the anvil cloud-head. Thunder and lightning are often observed when these clouds, known as cumulonimbus, are nearby.

What makes air stable or unstable?

It is the vertical profile of temperature, or lapse rate of the atmosphere, which determines whether an air mass is stable or not. The temperature can be measured using an electronic thermometer attached to a helium-filled weather balloon released from the ground. As it ascends, the readings are transmitted back to earth and, under normal circumstances, the temperature would be found to fall with height. But it does not always fall at the same lapse rate. If it falls rapidly with height, then the atmosphere is said to be unstable; if it falls more slowly (or even temporarily increases with height) then a stable atmosphere is present.

What happens to make clouds appear different in stable or unstable conditions?

In a recent post for this website, Frank Barrow described adiabatic processes involving ‘parcels’ of air rising through the atmosphere. These ‘parcels’ are subject to decreasing pressure as they ascend and adiabatic cooling results. The rate of cooling is known as the adiabatic lapse rate. Warm air is less dense than cold air. Therefore, if the air ‘parcel’ cools to a lower temperature than that of the surrounding air it has risen into, it will stop rising. Any cloud which may have formed inside the ‘parcel’ during the adiabatic cooling process will be of limited vertical extent as shown in Image 1.

Stable profile

Image 1: Graph of height against temperature in a stable situation with a temperature inversion (a layer in which the atmosphere warms with height). The air ‘parcel’ starts off warmer than the atmosphere at low levels and therefore it rises. However, it becomes cooler than the atmosphere above the level where the lines intersect. Therefore, it stops rising at that point. If the ‘parcel’ has cooled enough to enable condensation to occur (at the condensation level), only clouds of limited depth result.

However, if the air into which the ‘parcel’ has risen turns out to be colder than the ‘parcel’ itself, in spite of its adiabatic cooling, it will continue to rise more strongly. Any cloud formed in this situation will have a marked vertical extent, as in Image 2.

Unstable profile

Image 2: Graph of height against temperature in an unstable situation. The air ‘parcel’ is always warmer than the atmosphere at every level above the surface and therefore keeps rising. When the ‘parcel’ cools enough to enable condensation to occur (at the condensation level), tall cumulus clouds result.

What makes air rise in the first place?

There are several mechanisms by which air can be encouraged to start rising. These include:

  • Heating from below: If air is located over a surface which is warmer than it is, then it will be heated by the surface. This will make it less dense and it will start to rise
  • Coasts and hills: Physical barriers to air flow will force air to rise over them
  • Convergence: If two air flows meet from different directions, then one may be forced to rise over the other
  • Weather fronts: Rising air is associated with weather fronts

Those April Showers made famous by the rhyme, are therefore the result of instability in the atmosphere together with a trigger to get them started. However, in reality, things are a little more complicated. For a start, the value of the adiabatic lapse rate is not constant, depending upon both the temperature itself and whether or not cloud is forming as the parcel rises. Then, there is the intermediate position between stability and instability; a phenomenon known as conditional instability. That is when the atmosphere is essentially stable, up until something happens to flip the situation into an unstable one. But more of that in a future post……

Categories: Weather
Tags: Air Masses Clouds Convection

Our other Weather articles